Memory Beta:Votes for approval of supplemental images/approved

Chateau Thelian.jpg
VOTES: DISCUSSION I'm not certain whether this should stay in Château Thelian, but it could definately be used for the Château de Saint Brisson, which it actually is. That's all moot though unless we know how the source feels about the image, and I don't read French. --Chops 01:55, 25 April 2006 (UTC)
 * replace --Chops 01:55, 25 April 2006 (UTC)
 * neutral --Arcarsenal 03:00, 25 April 2006 (UTC)
 * yes --Sci 07:37 25 April 2006 UTC
 * yes --Emperorkalan 12:30, 25 April 2006 (UTC), modified--Emperorkalan 18:52, 26 April 2006 (UTC)
 * yes --Turtletrekker 08:45, 27 April 2006 (UTC)
 * I think it's safe to presume that the source doesn't much care, since there are about a billion pictures around. And I want to keep it there because I myself had a hard time imagining what Chateau Thelian might look like until I found this photo, which was coincidently of the Chateau de Saint Brisson, as you noted, the chateau that Articles of the Federation described Chateau Thelian as being similar to. -- Sci 07:39 25 April 2006 UTC

To switch me to a "yes":
 * 1) Identify the photo as the Château de Saint Brisson, which Thelian is directly compared with. Thelian, however seems to be a composite using features from many châteaux. The photo is thus there more as a sort of "rough sketch" of Thelian than an actual depiction.
 * 2) Quote the relevant text somewhere on the page, either in the main passage or in a Notes section.
 * 3) An external links to http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ch%C3%A2teaux_of_the_Loire_Valley and http://www.coeur-de-france.com/st-brisson-chateau.html (and for the latter, maybe also a link that goes through an online translator)--Emperorkalan 12:30, 25 April 2006 (UTC)


 * The photo was already identified as actually being of Château de Saint Brisson. The relevent quotations have been added to a "notes" section, and the external links you requested have also been integrated into the notation. -- Sci 17:44 26 April 2006 UTC
 * Also: I wasn't sure if you were asking that the Articles quotations be added to the image page or to the Château Thelian entry itself. I added the quotation to the image page; please let me know if I misinterpreted your request. -- Sci 17:64 26 April 2006 UTC
 * Actually, I WAS thinking of it going on the Thelian page, but mostly because I thought (for no particularly good reason) you couldn't do it on the image page. This serves just as well, and with less clutter.--Emperorkalan 19:15, 26 April 2006 (UTC)
 * Thanks for your thoroughness. Vote switched (see above)--Emperorkalan 18:52, 26 April 2006 (UTC)
 * I'm good with this one as is.--Turtletrekker 08:45, 27 April 2006 (UTC)


 * Is this chateau actually named in the book? If so, the image should be on it's own page, and we can have this pic at the Chateau Thelian with the message "The Chateau is described as strongly resembling..." so-and-so. - Lieutenant Ayala 16:29, 29 April 2006 (UTC)
 * Click on the image above to get to the page for the image itself. The text from the novel has been quoted in response to a request I made above. Does that affect your suggestion any?--Emperorkalan 16:42, 29 April 2006 (UTC)
 * Yes, the chateau that that is actually a photo of -- Chateau de Saint Brisson -- is mentioned in Articles. The novel also describes Chateau Thelian as being similar to Chateau de Saint Brisson, hence the use of it as a stand-in for Thelian until/unless a licensed pic comes along. What you suggest has already been done. -- Sci 03:48 30 April 2006 UTC