User talk:84.134.88.13

Edrich
I'm having trouble with the changes you have been making to the Edrich article -- you have twice edited the article so that it says Edrich was an admiral in the year 2370 -- Edrich was definitely a commodore in the year 2370. -- unsigned by IP user

I understand that Edrich might have been promoted to Admiral in a book that I haven't read -- you should probably start a new paragraph about this rather than altering the existing paragraph to make it inaccurate. Do you understand? -- Captain MKB 20:07, 17 June 2008 (UTC)


 * In the first line there should be his latest rank. Both appearances should be described, of course.– 84.134.88.13 19:13, 18 June 2008 (UTC)
 * PS: You should read Death in Winter its very good! -- unsigned by IP user

You are still missing my point -- please stop removing the word "commodore" from the article -- just because he was promoted, this does not make it ok for you to erase his previous rank as it is still part of his article. If you feel the information should be reorganized, please create a version of the article that contains references to both ranks. -- Captain MKB 20:28, 18 June 2008 (UTC)