Memory Beta, non-canon Star Trek Wiki

A friendly reminder regarding spoilers! At present the expanded Trek universe is in a period of major upheaval with the finale of Year Five, the Coda miniseries and the continuations of Discovery, Picard and Lower Decks; and the premieres of Prodigy and Strange New Worlds, the advent of new eras in Star Trek Online gaming, as well as other post-55th Anniversary publications. Therefore, please be courteous to other users who may not be aware of current developments by using the {{spoiler}}, {{spoilers}} or {{majorspoiler}} tags when adding new information from sources less than six months old. Also, please do not include details in the summary bar when editing pages and do not anticipate making additions relating to sources not yet in release. 'Thank You


Memory Beta, non-canon Star Trek Wiki

To err is Vulcan! – "To Err Is Vulcan" was a Star Trek comic book story published by Gold Key Comics in 1979, the 59th issue of Gold Key Comics' 1967 series of Star Trek TOS comics. It was the last of 21 stories written by Arnold Drake and the 20th drawn by Alden McWilliams.

In the story, Spock made not one, but two errors. James T. Kirk suspected a plan to discredit Spock, and had a plan of his own to figure out why.


The intellectual achievements of Mr. Spock are legendary throughout the United Federation of Planets… and beyond! But when that great mind suddenly turns foolish, the danger is beyond reckoning!


Captain's log, stardate 9126.1.
Have ordered briefing on next assignment, for 0700 hours, ship's time...

The planet Njura had long reigned over an empire, but an uprising led to disarmament, democracy and freedom in 2260. James T. Kirk, Spock and Leonard McCoy beamed down for a protocol visit and met the former emperor, now President Kring, who was cross-breeding bees. He assigned Doctor Mlany Rdal as their tour guide. They rode an electric car to one of the planet's nuclear fusion reactors. But when they checked a monitoring station, Spock calculated that two generators were about to explode and destroy half the planet. Rdal assured him that everything was safe.

Captain's log, supplemental: stardate 9126.1.
Convinced of a malfunction of two giant nuclear generators on the planet Njura, Mr. Spock took drastic action to halt them...

Spock cut power to 100 million Njurans, but a review of the data records showed that the equipment had been running safely, and that Spock apparently transposed two numbers in the data. Later, during a tour of the meteorological center, Spock saw that a tornado was headed right for their city. But Rdal confirmed that there was in fact no tornado, and Spock noted that an indicator had changed direction. Kirk placated a frustrated Rdal by having Spock return to the ship.

The next day, Rdal took Kirk and McCoy to a tenth anniversary peace parade, which featured fireworks, agricultural aircraft spraying perfume, and a formation of farming combines. The outer skins of the combines suddenly melted, exposing disguised tanks. Spock had planted thermal charges on the vehicles to publicly expose Kring's plan to reconquer his former empire. Spock further hampered the president by disabling the weather center and power plant. In a large stadium, Kirk saved face for Kring, announcing that the president had foiled the conspiracy. Later, Rdal said she had been unaware of the plot, and that Kring's advisors had orchestrated events to discredit Spock in order to prevent the Vulcan from figuring it out. Kirk had sent Spock back to the ship so he'd be able to investigate more freely.



James T. KirkKringSpockLeonard McCoyMlany RdalMontgomery ScottHikaru SuluNyota Uhura
Referenced only
Albert EinsteinGmarKsantha

Starships and vehicles

aircraftUSS Enterprise (Constitution-class heavy cruiser) • electric carsfarming combinestanks


Planets and planetoids

Njura system (Njura)
Referenced only
Earth (AlpsSwitzerland)

Stellar locations

the galaxy (Alpha or Beta Quadrant)

Races and cultures


States and organizations


Science and technology

agriculturecitycomputerelectrobionicsholographic projectorholographyisobarmeteorologymoleculemovienuclear powerobservatoryorbitphysicspoisonpower plantpressureradio telescopesatellitesickbaystarshipsubatomic energytelevisiontelevision camerathermal chargeThird Field Theorytransporterwarp drive

Ranks and titles

beekeepercaptainchief engineercommandercommanding officerchief medical officercommunications officerengineerdoctoremperorexecutive officerFederation Starfleet ranksFederation Starfleet ranks (2260s)generallieutenantlieutenant commanderpresidentprofessorscience officersoldiertechnician

Other references

atmospherebeecaptain's logcaptain's log, USS Enterprise (NCC-1701), 2270democracydoveemotionenergyfarmerfireworksgasgymnasiumhoneyhospitalhumanoidinsectinsignialogicmattermacoroco birdmetalparadeperfumeplanetpolicerankscientistScotsmanspacestarsystemstardateStarfleet uniformStarfleet uniform (2260s)teatimetitletornadouniformuniversevartaweaponwarwheat


13th century
Njura colonizes four neighboring planets in its star system. (1,000 years prior to story)
Njura ends a long period of war. (10 years prior to story)
Stardate 9126.1, 2270 (2270s chronology, 2270s Enterprise voyages)
Enterprise travels to Njura.


Related media


  • The title was a twist on the proverb "to err is human," first written by Alexander Pope in 1711. (An Essay on Criticism article at Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia.)
  • Outfitting of the ship's gymnasium with holographic projectors was an enhancement similar to the holodeck-like recreation room seen in TAS episode: "The Practical Joker".
  • Mlany Rdal wore four outfits during the course of the story: a blue and pink catsuit when she first appeared, a maroon catsuit while touring the nuclear plant, a short green-and-black striped dress during the parade, and a dark blue dress with white belt at the end of the story. Kring wore three outfits: a beekeeper suit, a red kimono during the tea meeting, and a collared purple outfit during the parade.
  • A small diamond decorating Rdal's forehead disappeared after page 9 in the middle of the scene.
  • Nyota Uhura was seen from the back in one panel. Hikaru Sulu manned the helm and had one line of dialogue.
  • Page four appeared to be a filler page or one that could be deleted for reprints. It devoted five panels to the Enterprise decelerating from warp speed.
  • The story has been reprinted in English and Indonesian.



Gold Key Comics stories and publications
Issues "The Planet of No Return" • "The Devil's Isle of Space" • "Invasion of the City Builders" • "The Peril of Planet Quick Change" • "The Ghost Planet" • "When Planets Collide" • "The Voodoo Planet" • "The Youth Trap" • "The Legacy of Lazarus" • "Sceptre of the Sun" • "The Brain Shockers" • "The Flight of the Buccaneer" • "Dark Traveler" • "The Enterprise Mutiny" • "Museum at the End of Time" • "Day of the Inquisitors" • "The Cosmic Cavemen" • "The Hijacked Planet" • "The Haunted Asteroid" • "A World Gone Mad" • "The Mummies of Heitius VII" • "Siege in Superspace" • "Child's Play" • "The Trial of Captain Kirk" • "Dwarf Planet" • "The Perfect Dream" • "Ice Journey" • "The Mimicking Menace" • "Death of a Star" • "The Final Truth" • "The Animal People" • "The Choice" • "The PsychoCrystals" • "A Bomb in Time" • "One of Our Captains Is Missing!" • "Prophet of Peace" • "Furlough to Fury" • "The Evictors" • "World Against Time" • "The World Beneath the Waves" • "Prince Traitor" • "Mr. Oracle" • "This Tree Bears Bitter Fruit" • "Murder on the Enterprise" • "A Warp in Space" • "Planet of No Life" • "Destination... Annihilation!" • "And a Child Shall Lead Them" • "What Fools These Mortals Be.." • “Sport of Knaves” • "A World Against Itself" • "No Time Like the Past" • "Spore of the Devil" • "The Brain-Damaged Planet" • "To Err Is Vulcan" • "The Empire Man!" • "Operation Con Game"
Additional stories "James T. Kirk: Psycho-File" • "A Page From Scotty's Diary" • "Spock: Psycho-File" • "From Sputnik to Warp Drive"
Collections Star Trek Annuals (1969197019721973197419751976197719781979198019831986) • The Enterprise Logs (Volumes 1234) • The Key Collection (Volumes 12345) • Gold Key Archives (Volumes 12345) • Gold Key 100-Page Spectacular
Related media "Voyage of Discovery" • "The Exile" • "The Red Hour" • "The Tunnel of Death" • "... Wild Goose Chase!" • "A Hint of Life" • "Space Chase" • "Escape from the Clinging Dags" • "Eye of the Beholder" • "The Menace of the Mechanitrons" • "Trial by Fire!"


Published Order
Previous comic:
The Brain-Damaged Planet
TOS comics (Gold Key) Next comic:
The Empire Man
Previous story:
Spore of the Devil
Stories by:
Arnold Drake
Next story:
last comic
Chronological Order
Previous adventure:
A World Against Itself
Memory Beta Chronology Next adventure:
The Price of the Phoenix
Previous comic:
A World Against Itself
Voyages of the USS Enterprise (NCC-1701), Year Five Next comic:
The Price of the Phoenix
Production history
January 1979
First published by Gold Key Comics.
Printed in Great Britain in hardcover in Star Trek Annual 1983. (Stafford Pemberton)
September 2008
Included on The Complete Comic Book Collection DVD. (Graphic Imaging Technologies)
25 April 2019
Reprinted in Graphic Novel Collection #61. (Eaglemoss Collections)
Indonesian: As "Spock Adu Otak" in b/w in Star Trek #5. (Cypress)

External links